top of page
Search

Pro Tem Judges in Small Claims Court: A Challenge for Security Deposit Disputes

Writer: stephaniesgermani
stephaniesgermani
Apr 20, 2025
4 min read

Updated: 29 minutes ago

Updated November 2026.

You don’t have to agree to have your case heard by a pro tem judge.

Security deposit disputes are among the most common landlord-tenant problems we see. When they land in small claims court, tenants often face two obstacles at once: landlords who ignore California’s security deposit law, and temporary judges who may not apply it correctly.

What the Law Requires of Landlords

Civil Code section 1950.5 requires a landlord to:

  • Return the deposit, or whatever is left of it, within 21 days after the tenant moves out

  • Give an itemized statement of every deduction

  • Include copies of invoices or receipts for any deduction of $125 or more

  • Tell the tenant they can request an initial inspection before moving out

  • Photograph the unit after getting it back and before any repairs or cleaning they plan to charge for, and again after the work is done, and send those photos with the itemized statement

  • Use the deposit only for unpaid rent, damage beyond ordinary wear and tear, cleaning needed to return the unit to its move-in condition, and restoring property the lease required the tenant to return

Since July 1, 2024, most landlords may also collect no more than one month’s rent as security.

When Landlords Ignore the Rules

One San Diego County commissioner calls them “lackadaisical landlords.” They miss the 21-day deadline, skip the itemized statement, never offer the pre-move-out inspection, and charge for ordinary wear and tear or for more cleaning than the unit needed.

When a landlord keeps a deposit in bad faith, the tenant can recover not only the money wrongly kept but also statutory damages of up to twice the amount of the deposit. In practice, though, bad-faith damages are awarded far less often than the law allows.

What Is a Pro Tem Judge?

Small claims court is designed for people without lawyers, so it is where most deposit disputes are heard. Because of the volume of cases, many small claims hearings are run by pro tem (temporary) judges rather than sitting judges.

Pro tem judges are volunteer attorneys. Under California Rules of Court, rule 2.812, they must have been State Bar members for at least 10 years (or 5 years if the presiding judge finds good cause), be in good standing, and complete training in bench conduct and ethics. For small claims, the substantive training is a course of at least three hours within the previous three years. Three hours does not go far in landlord-tenant law.

What Granberry Actually Says

Granberry v. Islay Investments (1995) 9 Cal.4th 738 is the California Supreme Court’s leading case on what happens when a landlord misses the 21-day deadline. The landlord must still return the deposit. But the Court held that a landlord whose failure to comply was in good faith does not lose the right to recover unpaid rent, repairs and cleaning, and may raise those claims as a setoff when the tenant sues for the deposit.

The key words are “in good faith.” A landlord who simply forgot a deadline but can prove real damage may still get credit for it. A landlord who never intended to return the deposit is in a very different position, and that is where the bad-faith penalty comes in.

A Troubling Example

A tenant sued her former landlord in San Diego County small claims court over a $4,000 deposit the landlord never returned or accounted for. When the pro tem judge asked whether the landlord had tried to return it, the landlord said, “Absolutely not.”

That admission goes straight to bad faith. The landlord gave no itemization, made no attempt to return the money, and said so in open court. The tenant should have recovered her deposit, and the court should at least have considered statutory damages. Instead, the pro tem judge ruled against her. Even when the facts are this clear, a temporary judge who doesn’t regularly hear deposit cases can get it wrong.

How to Protect Yourself

1. Know you can decline a pro tem judge. Under the Rules of Court, a temporary judge can hear your case only if the parties agree. You must be told that a temporary judge is assigned and that you have the right to have your case heard by a judge, commissioner or referee of the court. Saying no may mean your hearing is rescheduled, but it may be worth it.

2. Bring the law with you. Print Civil Code section 1950.5, a summary of Granberry, your lease, your messages with the landlord, your move-in and move-out photos, and any request you made for a pre-move-out inspection.

3. Name the violations. Don’t just ask for your deposit back. Point to the parts of section 1950.5 the landlord broke, walk the court through the timeline, and explain why the landlord’s conduct was bad faith.

4. Know your options after the hearing. A plaintiff cannot appeal a small claims judgment on their own claim. But either party may file a Request to Correct or Cancel Judgment (Form SC-108) on the ground that the decision had an incorrect or erroneous legal basis. You must file it within 30 days after the clerk mails the Notice of Entry of Judgment, and each party may file only one.

Knowledge Is Your Best Protection

Attorneys can’t represent you at a small claims hearing, but a consultation beforehand can help you prepare. If you are facing a security deposit dispute, contact us through our website to schedule a consultation.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
How to Be a Great Client

Updated November 2026. You play a bigger role in your case than you might think. The more smoothly we work together, the faster and more affordably we can get you results. Here is what makes the bigge

 
 
 

Comments


Germani Law · Stephanie S. Germani, Esq. · 450 S. Melrose Drive, Suite 100, Vista, CA 92081 (by appointment) · 619-825-1133 · info@germanilaw.com
 

Attorney Advertising. Attorney Stephanie S. Germani is responsible for this website. Nothing on this website is legal advice, and viewing it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Do not send confidential information through this website.

©2026 Germani Law

bottom of page